The Charcot Journal

             ISSN 3103-6090

Interdisciplinary Studies in the History of Neurology

The Soul Reconsidered: Antonio Fogazzaro (1842–1911) Reads Charcot in For a New Science (Per una nuova Scienza, 1898)

Author: Francesco Brigo

Affiliation: Innovation, Research and Teaching Service, Teaching Hospital of the Paracelsus Medical Private University (PMU), Azienda Sanitaria dell’Alto Adige, Bolzano, Italy.

Abstract: This article examines the overlooked intellectual connection between Italian novelist Antonio Fogazzaro (1842–1911) and French neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot (1825–1893), with particular focus on Fogazzaro’s 1898 lecture Per una nuova Scienza (“For a New Science”). Charcot—renowned for his groundbreaking work on hysteria and hypnotism—serves in Fogazzaro’s thought as both a literal and symbolic gatekeeper between the rigid empiricism of positivist science and the emergence of a spiritually attuned scientific paradigm. Fogazzaro, deeply committed to reconciling science and faith, interprets Charcot’s public endorsement of hypnotism as a cultural turning point that legitimized previously marginalized psychic phenomena. Through vivid allegory, he portrays Charcot’s acceptance of hypnotism as the opening of the gates of “official science” to a procession of outlawed ideas such as telepathy, spiritualism, and mental suggestion. Engaging with a broad intellectual tradition—from Franz Anton Mesmer to Pierre Janet and Charles Richet—Fogazzaro constructs a learned yet critical narrative of 19th-century scientific and spiritual discourse. He challenges the reductive tendencies of materialist positivism for excluding the soul and advocates for a new science that would integrate Western empirical methods with Eastern metaphysical insights. While cautious of spiritualist excesses, Fogazzaro sees in phenomena like hypnotism evidence of a deeper, irreducible spiritual principle within the human being. Ultimately, he positions himself as a mediator between faith and reason, science and soul—an intellectual poised at the threshold of a new spiritual science.

Keywords: Charcot, Jean-Martin; Fogazzaro, Antonio; Hypnotism; Hysteria; Positivism; Spiritualism

Published in: The Charcot Journal, 2025, Volume 1, Issue 1, Pages 4–14

Download PDF: 2025_V1_I1_Brigo_Fogazzaro

How to cite this article: Brigo F. The Soul Reconsidered: Antonio Fogazzaro (1842–1911) Reads Charcot in For a New Science (Per una nuova Scienza, 1898). The Charcot Journal. 2025; 1(1):4-14.